|
Post by friend on Nov 3, 2019 23:46:49 GMT
Because I hadn't posted in the 5 days from the 30th of October to the 3rd of November (I shouldn't have been inactive for that long - I apologize for that) I felt it necessary to mention that I tend to be quiet during D1 as town, and then mattwereddy and others decided start a bandwagon based off that statement. To be honest, I've just been playing very erratically for fun, and to create discussion - it's early days yet (5 days left.) I'm sorry if anyone took my posts to be 100% serious - they aren't. I've never understood D1 strategy as town in the forum format to be honest, it generally feels like a total stab in the dark at the time. I'll take a proper read through the thread tomorrow. Which part of your posts were serious, and what were jokes? You're maybe mafia right now.
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 0:34:07 GMT
To be honest, I've just been playing very erratically for fun, and to create discussion I am Matthew and I have not observed you playing erratically. I have observed you not playing.
|
|
|
Post by alljokesaside on Nov 4, 2019 17:20:05 GMT
Why would you not also look at alljokesaside who has the same aversion to a day 1 eliminate but gives no reasoning for it and I think is more suspicious? Since this is my first forum game, I'm still not sure as to how to read effectively (see: at all), and since I usually play more passively irl, I see how this makes me seem much more suspicious. Observing and deducing is usually my play of preference, but I'm learning that this won't do in forum play.
I assure that I am not scum, but have no way of confirming this in a way that the town would accept.
|
|
|
Post by jcraster on Nov 4, 2019 18:23:24 GMT
Because I hadn't posted in the 5 days from the 30th of October to the 3rd of November (I shouldn't have been inactive for that long - I apologize for that) I felt it necessary to mention that I tend to be quiet during D1 as town, and then mattwereddy and others decided start a bandwagon based off that statement. To be honest, I've just been playing very erratically for fun, and to create discussion - it's early days yet (5 days left.) I'm sorry if anyone took my posts to be 100% serious - they aren't. I've never understood D1 strategy as town in the forum format to be honest, it generally feels like a total stab in the dark at the time. I'll take a proper read through the thread tomorrow. Which part of your posts were serious, and what were jokes? You're maybe mafia right now. The first post I made was serious, the second (where I accused scum of being baited and said half the town was suspicious) was me messing around. I was unaware than alljokesaside was in the game, they are a better eliminate candidate than Deodat Lawson in my opinion.
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 18:35:53 GMT
Which part of your posts were serious, and what were jokes? You're maybe mafia right now. The first post I made was serious, the second (where I accused scum of being baited and said half the town was suspicious) was me messing around. I was unaware than alljokesaside was in the game, they are a better eliminate candidate than Deodat Lawson in my opinion.
I am Matthew and I am getting that you couldn't be bothered to read through 5 pages of content before making a statement. This is looking worse and worse for you. If they're a better candidate why have you not voted for them?
|
|
|
Post by jcraster on Nov 4, 2019 19:08:14 GMT
The first post I made was serious, the second (where I accused scum of being baited and said half the town was suspicious) was me messing around. I was unaware than alljokesaside was in the game, they are a better eliminate candidate than Deodat Lawson in my opinion.
I am Matthew and I am getting that you couldn't be bothered to read through 5 pages of content before making a statement. This is looking worse and worse for you. If they're a better candidate why have you not voted for them? Putting aside the impact inactivity has on the game, did I ever claim otherwise? I skimread at the time and really didn't see anything that stood out beyond Deodat suggesting no eliminate as a strategy. (I'm also surprised Demesne asked about daychat given that would almost always be secret.)
vote: alljokesaside
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 19:29:35 GMT
I am Matthew and I am getting that you couldn't be bothered to read through 5 pages of content before making a statement. This is looking worse and worse for you. If they're a better candidate why have you not voted for them? Putting aside the impact inactivity has on the game, did I ever claim otherwise? I am Matthew and I don't see why you wouldn't. 5 pages is nothing.
|
|
|
Post by redleader on Nov 4, 2019 21:30:20 GMT
jcraster has doubled down again on the 'Oh idk what's happening' strategy from Endor and Yavin 4. Classic scum manoeuvre.
Vote: jcraster
P.S. Fair point mattwereddy about affecting ersand with votes.
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 22:06:42 GMT
I am Matthew and I am going to point out now, given that Jcraster is on L-3, that when voting for larger wagons it's good form to state when you are placing a player at L-2 and L-1 so there are no "accidental" hammers. This is especially important in this game where votes can be easy to miss. For those of you unfamiliar with the jargon L-x represents the number of votes away from being lynched a player is. L-2 means eliminate - 2 votes or two votes from being lynched. A hammer vote is simply the last vote that results in the eliminate.
|
|
|
Post by Vector Si͈͍̣̹͍̱̖͢g̮̩m̰̠͓͙̲a on Nov 4, 2019 22:09:18 GMT
VOTECOUNT 4/11/2019
WITH 16 ALIVE IT TAKES 9 VOTES TO eliminate. With only 15 currently playing it takes 8 votes to eliminate.
jcraster - (Milktoffee, mattwereddy, Deodat Lawson, redleader, friend, flopz) 6 mario - (Demesne King, lynchthequietpeople) 2
mattwereddy - (hippocrates) 1
Deodat Lawson - (50 Percent Banana) 1
russianbot - (mario) 1 ersand - (alljokesaside) 1
alljokesaside - (jcraster) 1
NOT VOTING - (basmu, russianbot, ersand) 3
|
|
|
Post by friend on Nov 4, 2019 22:30:57 GMT
Jcraster is acting a lot like mafia so I'm kind of desided on him. He originally said the people being suspisious of him and voting for him were suspisious. But now he claims he was just joking around when he said that. I don't believe him but this feels too easy.
I'm new to forum mafia so am open to having my mind changed on this. Could someone who's played with Jcraster tell us how he usually plays on day 1?
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 22:41:57 GMT
I'm new to forum mafia so am open to having my mind changed on this. Could someone who's played with Jcraster tell us how he usually plays on day 1? I am Matthew and I think it would help if those people were active and playing which is very much the biggest problem with this game as it stands. jcraster who do you think I am?
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 22:44:49 GMT
I am Matthew and I would also like jcraster to tell us which players have played with him before.
|
|
|
Post by Thilbert on Nov 4, 2019 22:48:10 GMT
Player ersand has been replaced by player HibboDude! Please give them a warm welcome.
15 playing still means 8 to eliminate
|
|
|
Post by jcraster on Nov 4, 2019 23:06:36 GMT
I'm new to forum mafia so am open to having my mind changed on this. Could someone who's played with Jcraster tell us how he usually plays on day 1? I am Matthew and I think it would help if those people were active and playing which is very much the biggest problem with this game as it stands. jcraster who do you think I am? Activity in the last 24 hours in particular has been poor, we've had ~5 people post. That leaves ~9 people (as I posted over 24hrs ago) who have said nothing about this bandwagon, which is the most consequential thing that's happened. I talked to Matthew who told me that you are not in fact Matthew (and I'm inclined to believe this isn't a double bluff.) Louis is the next obvious candidate, especially since the picture of you appears to be in a kitchen or a physics lab so could easily have been taken by him, and also because your posting style and tone fit the game Pick your Power I modded with Louis in it: warwick-mafia.freeforums.net/user/61/recentWould Louis pretend to exit the game and create a Spite Mafia game just to make his Matthew claim look stronger - yes. He could easily have planned this with Tom. This seems like an easy answer though. Too easy. But who else could it be? People it can't be: Tom (well I guess it could be, but that would be bastard) Ibad (ok well you never know, but I'll just have to ignore this possibility) Ben Matthew ^ These three based on in-person conversations
|
|
|
Post by mattwereddy on Nov 4, 2019 23:18:56 GMT
13) This setup is most assuredly bastard. I am Matthew and that is all I would like to say at this point in time.
|
|
|
Post by jcraster on Nov 4, 2019 23:19:19 GMT
I am Matthew and I would also like jcraster to tell us which players have played with him before. Demesne King is the only player who has played with me on the forum (except for whoever you are.) I recognise many other names on the list, but I haven't played with any of them on the forum, just in person or on Discord.
|
|
|
Post by jcraster on Nov 4, 2019 23:24:07 GMT
13) This setup is most assuredly bastard. I am Matthew and that is all I would like to say at this point in time. Hah, I hadn't noticed that, I just assumed those were the standard rules we use every game. My favourite rule is always 18) I can change any and all rules as and when I please.
|
|
|
Post by Milktoffee on Nov 4, 2019 23:26:57 GMT
I am almost completely confident that @mattwereddy is not Matthew; but that doesn't matter with regards to the game.
|
|
|
Post by hippocrates on Nov 5, 2019 2:28:47 GMT
I was busy for a couple of days and come back to this load of shenanigans... the matthew mystery is too complex to handle, but they seem to be talking the most along with jcraster, which leads me to believe they're townies. Unless they're really talkative mafia.
Can I ask, is there any way to change who you voted for (to eliminate) in forum mafia? I voted earlier on when I had little reads but i'm more inclined to think "i am matthew and i think" is a townie now
|
|
|
Post by Alpha Trion on Nov 5, 2019 10:16:54 GMT
Is there any way to change who you voted for (to eliminate) in forum mafia? Just say what you’d like your vote to switch to, or say you’d like to unvote.
|
|
|
Post by friend on Nov 5, 2019 12:16:23 GMT
hippocrates Jcraster has only been active since people starting accusing him. Is there any other reason you think he is town? Does the 11.5 game have anything to do with this one?
|
|
|
Post by Alpha Trion on Nov 5, 2019 12:35:36 GMT
Demesne King, 50 Percent Banana, mario and lynchthequietpeople have all been prodded
|
|
|
Post by Alpha Trion on Nov 5, 2019 12:49:04 GMT
Does the 11.5 game have anything to do with this one? No
|
|
|
Post by HibboDude on Nov 5, 2019 13:11:18 GMT
Hey, I was in another tab! I don't have the time to constantly check the site at all times. What discussion do you wish to have? I don't really have any conversation starters. I am Matthew and I and surprised you cannot tell that I would like you to reveal your true identity. When you say true identity, do you mean who you are in real life, or who you are in mafia? Because i'm pretty sure your claim of Bulgarian train joke driver whatsit isn't a role ;P
|
|
|
Post by HibboDude on Nov 5, 2019 13:12:49 GMT
Oh holy hell ignore this. ^^^^^^ i didnt realise there was 6 pages of stuff to read first O.O
But in other news, Hi All! I've been subbed in for an inactive player. Let me quickly try to actually catch up...
|
|
|
Post by HibboDude on Nov 5, 2019 13:47:09 GMT
Okay, just about all read up.
My conclusions: Difinitely eliminate Day 1. Mafia have information, town don't. It's a pretty big disadvantage. Lynching gets us information. Yes, we are more likely to hit a townie than mafia, but its worth it. Also, mafia are typically more powerful at night, so each day town are inactive, better for mafia.
Therefore to jump on the bandwagon, Vote: jcraster. I honestly feel a little bad if you say so many games you died day one, and here i am trying to eliminate you day one, but maybe you should consider that maybe you die so often day one because of something you do / say? xD
I also believe MattweReddy to be town. I also believe MattweReddy to not be Mattew Reddy. So for shits and giggles, and because he's mentioned it twice, I would like to counter-claim Mattew Reddy.
Also I would like to ask everyone: do we have Investigative roles that want to call out for a protector? Unfortunately I am not an investigator of any variety, so I won't ask for it myself. But this way protectors can stay annonymous and can do something hopefully more helpful than a random protect.
|
|
|
Post by Demesne King on Nov 5, 2019 16:04:27 GMT
friend and mattwereddy are both townreads, basmu 's posts are extremely hard to read.
|
|
|
Post by Demesne King on Nov 5, 2019 16:10:08 GMT
Switching my vote (though I remain suspicious of alljokesaside). Vote: jcrasterI don't like this sudden change in vote. It'd be useful to know who you are to understand why you did this/so suddenly.
|
|
|
Post by Demesne King on Nov 5, 2019 16:15:09 GMT
Jcraster is a better player than he is giving himself credit right now. I am Matthew and I think it would help if those people were active and playing which is very much the biggest problem with this game as it stands. jcraster who do you think I am? Activity in the last 24 hours in particular has been poor, we've had ~5 people post. That leaves ~9 people (as I posted over 24hrs ago) who have said nothing about this bandwagon, which is the most consequential thing that's happened. I talked to Matthew who told me that you are not in fact Matthew (and I'm inclined to believe this isn't a double bluff.) Louis is the next obvious candidate, especially since the picture of you appears to be in a kitchen or a physics lab so could easily have been taken by him, and also because your posting style and tone fit the game Pick your Power I modded with Louis in it: warwick-mafia.freeforums.net/user/61/recentWould Louis pretend to exit the game and create a Spite Mafia game just to make his Matthew claim look stronger - yes. He could easily have planned this with Tom. This seems like an easy answer though. Too easy. But who else could it be? People it can't be: Tom (well I guess it could be, but that would be bastard) Ibad (ok well you never know, but I'll just have to ignore this possibility) Ben Matthew ^ These three based on in-person conversations
This is fairly trivial information formatted to look like an investment in the game. It would be more copacetic for you to share your townreads.
|
|